be surprised by a selection of what’s super delicious right now
Get excited about a fun way to experiment with new cheeses. Owner, Megan, will surprise you with cheeses that are super delicious right now. Each box is different and unique but always delicious and contains a variety of different styles and types of cheeses based on what is seasonally delicious right now.
Party Gift Box
Regular price
$140.00
Save $-140.00
/
a complete cheese platter for up to 6 people
Everything you need for a cheese party of up to 6 people. A gift box includes:
.5 lbs of 3 different seasonal cheeses
full description cards of each cheese
Your choice of Effies Biscuits
3 oz jar of Sidehill Farm Jam
2 oz Jar of Stormy Acres Wildflower Honey
Meat Crafters Salami
Victory Cheese Bundle
Regular price
$165.00
Save $-165.00
/
Be a part of keeping American farms open and supported during the Covid-19 crisis. 10% of sales donated to Anne Saxelby Legacy Fund
Covid-19 has left the American cheese industry extremely vulnerable. Many small farms and specialty artisans across the country are hurting right now. Let’s work together to keep them open. Each purchase of a Victory Cheese box is a 10% donation to World Central Kitchen and gets you:
The most ideal expression of American cheddar cheese, this cheddar will win over crowds for sure. It is full flavored with a creamy and warm palate finishing so sweet and grassy.
Semi firm goat wheel covered in flowers and herbs.
A gorgeous 1 lb semi-hard wheel covered in beautiful flowers and herbs- the perfect Summer cheese- even if it’s not quite Summer. The paste is mild and buttery flavor while the herbs and flowers on the outside makes for an incredibly aromatic palate reminiscent of walking through a grassy field of flowers and lavender
Celebrate the winning cheeses from the 2023 American Cheese Society Judging Competition. Each box will contain an assortment of styles of cheeses- every one of them will be winners.
Celebrate and savor the winers of this year's American Cheese Society Judging Competition. Owner, Megan, will surprise you with a variety of cheeses that were winners this year. Each box is different and unique but always delicious.
a $55 box includes at least 1.25 lbs of cheese
a $75 box includes at least 2 lbs of cheese
a $150 box includes at least 4 lbs of cheese
Bay Blue
Regular price
$10.00
Save $-10.00
/
A punchy and bright blue
This Stilton-esque blue is sure to satisfy the blue loves and Maryland cheese fanatics alike. The paste is creamy and bright with a punchy mineral finish and a definite briney palate.
The perfect expression of terroir- this collaboration between Anne Saxelby in NYC and Jasper Hill Farm in VT won First Runner Up for Best of Show by the American Cheese Society in 2018. The wheels are brine washed for six months then coated in hay from Jasper Hill’s one of a kind cropping center. The cheese is an exploration into the impact of the cow’s diet o n the finished cheese. It is firm, nutty, and complex with flavors of caramel, chestnut honey, earth, toasted bread, and tropical fruit.
Beautiful hand ladled loaves have incredible longevity-changing from bright and young to robust, savory, and creamy over their 2 month post ageing lives. The fluffy and lactic paste is surprisingly mushroomy and savory with bright acid and a clean finish
These 2 pound wheels are bright and lactic. Their size makes perfect for eating out of hand or for baking with fruits and nuts for large parties. Either way, it is creamy and gooey with notes of lemon, mushroom, and onion, and grassy palate and a bright lactic finish.
This yellow was dipped cheese is the perfect grilled cheese cheese (can we say cheese 1 more time in a sentence?). Melty and delicious with a bright, sweet, nutty, and tangy finish.
A classic cheddar- the cheddaring process lends a great milled texture perfect for cooking or snacking. It is bright and smooth with a lovely nutty finish.
These beautiful 8 pound square tomme-style wheels are one of Meadow Creek Dairy’s 3 produced cheeses and were the Dairy’s first cheese ever produced. Creamy and velvety, Appalachian is so easy to love. The notes of cream, lemon, butter, and mushroom are all perfectly balanced with a long and vibrant finish.
A craveable 1-year old gouda with incredible texture
Owned by Tammy and Ron Lubsen who immigrated from the Netherlands in 1980, Forx Farm buys its high-quality milk from Southern Oaks Jersey Farm & Creamery just 30 minutes away. This 1 year old gouda has tropical fruit flavors with notes of toasted nuts and sweet cream.
So easy to love- this cheese is super creamy with a long and sweet finish. It is smooth and bright with a long finish reminiscent of cave- musty, sweet, and grassy
A perfectly balanced ode to the South with local whiskey soaked fig leaves
An ode to the south- these wheels are wrapped in Chattanooga Whiskey soaked local fig leaves. It is complex and nuanced with a fun balance of salty-sweet-savory. Notes of sassafras, bacon, dark chocolate, and tropical fruit
Head to the top of the mountain with this six-ounce pyramid of bloomy, ashed, slightly blue deliciousness!. The patchy blue, grey, and white mold rind gives way to a creamline soul and a flyffy interior that tastes like minerals and hay.
Imagine a cheese with the pleasant qualities of cheddar but with a funky finish- you've got Amber 16. Washed in Amber Sun Ale from 16 Mile Brewing Company in Delaware. The bright orange rind has a very slight bloom while the paste is a slightly funky and bitter with a long and sweet finish.
An Alpine style wheel which is the perfect cheese expression of the farm’s mountainous terrain.
These beautiful 14 lb Alpine-style wheels are one of Meadow Creek Dairy’s 3 produced cheeses. It is smooth and supple cheese with a paste that dissolves on the tongue- buttery rich with notes of roasted nuts and finishing with a rich, beefy, and caramel flavors
The most awarded cheese in American history- and for good reason
incredibly sweet from the grass-fed milk while still having a savory finish from the natural and slightly washed rind. super rich and complex, salty with a long and fruity finish.
These 4-5 pound wheels are made in the traditional Manchego basket molds and have a beautifully textured oily rind. It is the perfect cheese for snacking with cured meats and wine- crumbly, salty, and delicious. It is incredibly full bodied with all the flavors of sheep’s milk- salty, meaty, and herbaceous
A truly unique aged goat’s milk that is surprisingly creamy and floral
This wonderfully delicate and creamy semi-hard goat's milk cheese is made using traditional cheesemaking techniques with modern equipment. With a long floral and granular finish, Verigoat is a perfectly delicious cheese- great for snacking, cheese boards, or cooking.
A young but super satisfying cheddar that is easy to fall in love with
The owners, Emily Bryant and Jay Montgomery believe that yummy cheese comes from happy cows and are committed to making sure their herd of 180 Holstein cows are healthy and happy while they graze on over 50 acres (of the farm’s 330). Barn Red Ched is super sweet and creamy with a floral and fruity finish and a texture that is sticky and mouth coating.
the flagship blue of Jasper Hill Farm and a stellar representation of blue cheese
Though there was never a major battle in Greensboro during the Revolutionary War, the Bayley Hazen road was a very important part of Greensboro history- bringing the area’s first settlers and continuing to be used today. Named for the road built by George Washington’s troops with the attempt of a Canadian invasion, this Jasper Hill Farm original is way too delicious. It is creamy, chocolaty, and salty, this blue has the perfect balance of luscious fat and bright acid.
These nearly 40 pound wheels are bound in cloth and do their aging in the caves at Jasper Hill Farm. of the 6 caves located at Jasper Hill Far, one entire cave is committed exclusively to the aging of this special cheddar and helps to fund the rest of the gaining facility on the farm. The wheels are grassy and herbaceous with a long a bright finish.
the namesake of Capriole Farm is this soft and pretty wheel covered in flower petals, herbs, and fennel pollen
Stunning 1/3 lb wheels of fresh goaty deliciousness that are the definition of eating first with our eyes. Feast away on the delicate, tart, and lactic with its fine and airy texture and flavors of fresh grass, herbs, and flowers. The rind is covered in fresh flower petals, herbs, and fennel pollen.
This lactic wheel is dense, gooey, creamy ,and beautifully minerally
These wheels are stunningly beautiful showcasing the color difference between the bright white paste and the dark ask rind. The beautiful cream line under the ashed rind gives way to a paste that is robust, unctuous, and earthy
Beautifully sweet like ripe strawberries with a crumbly and crunchy texture and a stellar salty finish
Lissome
Regular price
$9.50
Save $-9.50
/
a creamy and meaty stinky washed rind
This big, beefy, beer-laden washed rind has been washed regularly with beer during aging resulting in a flavors of cured meat, fresh cream, and a long lush finish
A salty, meaty, and beefy wheel studded with black truffles
Black Tuscan truffles laced through this cheese make for a delightfully decadent experience. Sheep’s milk buttery goodness mixes beautifully with the earthy richness from the summer truffles making every bite truly special.
The perfect Alpine cheese with a smooth and balanced paste
This perfectly balanced sweet and savory hard cheese has a beautifully granular yet firm texture and flavors of roasted almonds and thyme with a long and subtly sweet and herbaceous finish.
Gorgeous balls of ashed rind goat's milk ideal for aging. Beneath her wrinkly exterior lies a complexity not often found in such a young cheese. When young, its thin skin is white and slightly wrinkled. Closer to 5 weeks old its dryer and crumbling, becoming more wrinkled, allowing the ash to shine through. Notes of lemon, allspice, and a distinct goat tang show through with a milk flavor and light, firm texture
You think you know the classic Bobolink Cheddar? Wait until you meet her much older counterpart. • The extensive aging time of this cheese changes it completely. Full of tyrosine crystals for crunch, this cheddar will surprise you with how bright and fruity it is! A perfect choice for snacking.Considering the milk...
So unique and yet so snackable - the perfect cheddar for your cheese drawer at home!
All the things you love about goat cheese and cheddar rolled into one! With the bright white paste indicative of goat cheese, Pure Luck offers bright, grassy, tangy flavors, but also provides the quintessential crumbliness and crunchiness of an aged cheddar.
This award winning wheel is beautifully sweet and starchy
Named for the plateau surrounding the farm, this wheel is fruity and tangy with an aroma of dried leaves finishing with a fruity tang like cultured buttermilk and sweet hay.
If salted butter wanted to be cheese, it would be these beautiful little wheels of bliss!
A truly lush experience all the way around. When the wheels are still young, the paste of this cheese is sticky and supple, with a tang that reminds you of cultured butter. The longer it continues to ripen, the wheel will soften and the paste nearly melts upon cutting into it. The flavors will also mature into more earthy tones, like savory truffles.
lined and dusted with smoked paprika- these are the perfect goat-y snack
This pretty wheel's white rind becomes wrinkled with occasional spots of blue. Piper is carefully hand-ladled into individual molds. The flavor profile gets more buttery with age, breaking down into a thick cream line and a fudgy paste that adds to its silky lusciousness even 5 – 6 weeks later.
Considering the milk…
• pasteurized goat’s milk
What’s the type?
• a soft, mold ripened rind dusted with a slight coating of paprika
These massive wheels of aged sheep’s milk are a true joy to snack on
During the make, curds are cut very small and then heated to remove additional moisture before being molded at 50 lb wheels and pressed for over a day. During aging, they are regularly rubbed with olive oil to reduce mold growth and seal in moisture. The cheese has a granular and crystalline paste is nutty, smoky, fruity, and sweet with notes of waxy white flowers and balanced salt
Considering the milk…
raw sheep’s milk aged for at least 5 months on Ash wood slabs
Simply the best ricotta we've had- perfectly salty and moist
Serve with fruit and honey, roasted nuts, avocado and everything crumble, or straight with a spoon- every way you eat this, it is simply perfect with just the right amount of salt and moisture.
A balanced smokey wheel with the perfect stinky finish
Campo brings along with it a delicious reminder of Italy! Named not only for its Italian translation of “field”, but also for the sensory image of a campfire gathering that it conjures up. It takes on hints of toasted walnut and brown butter, while a flavor of beautiful cured meat surfaces.
A bright and balanced blue that would be appreciated by both the novice and experienced blue-enjoyer!
A total winner all the way around. The bright saltiness of the milk mixed with the punchiness of the blue balances in a way that would be enjoyable in anything from a grilled cheese to a salad. The creamier texture also makes it perfect to spread on any cracker or toast!
These little logs are packed with bright lactic flavor that only gets richer the longer it ripens.
These wheels are fresh and young, this wheel is bright and tangy like cultured butter, but as it ripens, the paste turns rich and luscious with a mushroom-y earthiness.
This semi-firm cow’s milk mountain style is cave aged resulting in a very complex paste with notes of cream, lemon, and nuts with a long and delicate finish
This sweet and buttery stand-out with a funky beer-washed rind is well deserving of its name: BAM! Booze!
This cheese will surprise you with how mellow of a stink she carries. Washed with beer from Cinderlands Beer Co. in Pittsburgh, the rind gives just enough robust meatiness while the inner paste offers a sweet and fruity flavor. A total winner in the summertime with some prosciutto and fresh peaches!
This aged washed rind is granular and pretty- perfect for snacking
The paste is nutty and granular with a floral and structured backbone. The rind has a light milk wax which, when peeled away, reveals the light wash of the rind
A grassy and creamy gem that’ll surprise you with just the right amount of kick.
This cheese is super creamy and sticky, the washed curds of the cheese are so sweet and smooth with a grassy finish all underlined by the spicy notes from the peppers
rubbed with smoked Spanish paprika, this mixed milk cheese is guaranteed to stand out on any cheese board
This cheese is named for the flowers of the Eastern Redbud tree. Boxcarr Handmade Cheese is run by siblings Samantha and Austin Genke. The paste is firm and nutty, while the rind gives a touch of smoke and bright, grippy zing.
A beautiful, sweet creamy cheese and a great cup of coffee rolled into one!
These big, rich, and nutty wheels are absolutely stunning with their pale white paste and super dark rind. The cheese has major notes of umami and buttermilk with a robust and lingering finish.
A gorgeous and complex blue with a nuanced a subtle finish
Made with the super rich raw milk from Holstein cows, this cheese is beautifully marbled with deep pockets of dark blue veins. It has a lovely and bright paste with a subtle and delicate palate and a creamy yellow paste.
This firm and slightly smoky blue is dynamic and fun
Right in the heart of the Oley Valley in South eastern Pennsylvania, Valley Milkhouse produces incredible cheeses in the tradiaiontal European styles sourcing their incredible grass fed organic milk from Berks County’s Kerith Brook Farm. The slightly firmer paste is crubly when cut but melts in your mouth with a smoky delicate finish and flavors of roasted fruits and toasted nuts.
A unique and well balanced blue that is approachable enough to turn anyone into a blue cheese fan!
Intended to be aged for 9 months, consumer demand and limited space resulted in a 4-month aging. This cheese only gets better with age, as the flavors develop deeper complexity and sweetness. It is creamy, dense, and buttery, with a hint of mild sweetness
A shattering 2-year old gouda with incredible texture
Owned by Tammy and Ron Lubsen who immigrated from the Netherlands in 1980, Forx Farm buys its high-quality milk from Southern Oaks Jersey Farm & Creamery just 30 minutes away. This 2 year old gouda is bright and zippy with incredible texture and flavors of pineapple, toasted nuts, and sweet milk.
A beautifully balanced goat’s milk studded with fresh chives.
Boxcarr Handmade Cheese is made up of family working alongside their amazing team. Grandparents, great-grandparents, cousins, along with the Genke’s children, a part of their hardworking team. This beautiful cheese of theirs is bright and milky with the zip of chives and a fun fluffy rind